The Latest Rub on Sunscreen

The Latest Rub on Sunscreen

seattle times logoOriginal Article by Jodie Tillman. We all do it. We slather on the sunscreen and think ourselves invincible. But are we putting our trust in the wrong hands? This article from The Seattle Times gives us the latest ‘rub’ on what’s really going into the sunscreens on the market.

Sunscreens sold in the United States are missing some of the latest and most effective ingredients for blocking the type of ultraviolet rays associated with premature aging and serious skin cancer.

Few items that beachgoers use are as distinctly American as their bottles, tubes and cans of sunscreen. But that shouldn’t be a point of pride, according to a coalition of dermatologists, cancer-research groups and sunscreen makers.

Sunscreens sold in the United States are missing some of the latest and most effective ingredients for blocking the type of ultraviolet rays associated with premature aging and serious skin cancer, says the Public Access to Sunscreens Coalition (PASS).

Those ingredients, though widely used in Europe and Asia, have been held up for years at the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Federal law treats sunscreen as an over-the-counter drug, meaning new formulas must undergo rigorous and costly scrutiny before they hit stores.

The coalition is making a public push for the FDA to get moving. The centerpiece of its efforts is proposed federal legislation, the Sunscreen Innovation Act, which would give FDA a timeline for acting on sunscreen applications.

“Everybody agrees that the process is broken down,” said Wendy Selig, president of the Melanoma Research Alliance, which is part of the PASS coalition.

It’s difficult to pinpoint the reasons for the delays. FDA officials have cited staffing shortages and a lengthy rule-writing process. In 2002, the agency set up what was intended to be a streamlined process for sunscreens, allowing officials to approve ingredients if they have been used for at least five years abroad and have proved effective and safe.

But no ingredients have been approved through that process. Eight applications are pending, some dating to 2003.

FDA spokeswoman Andrea Fischer said Americans have many effective products from which to choose.

She also pointed out FDA notifications to three applicants this year that their scientific evidence is lacking. In other countries, sunscreen is treated as a cosmetic, and the safety data from its use there doesn’t always meet FDA requirements.

“The FDA recognizes the public-health importance of sunscreen use and has prioritized reviewing the safety and effectiveness of additional sunscreen ingredients as quickly as possible given the agency’s resources,” Fischer said.

The FDA has methods for fast-tracking approvals of drugs for serious or life-threatening conditions. Selig noted that in the past four years, there have been at least six new drugs approved for melanoma, the deadliest skin cancer. But there has not been one new sunscreen ingredient approved in that time.

“It’s the same agency,” she said.

Dr. James Spencer, a St. Petersburg dermatologist, said U.S. sunscreens are good at protecting against ultraviolet B rays, which are primarily responsible for sunburns and can cause skin cancers. Protection from UVB is what people shop for when they select sunscreen by its SPF rating.

But he and other dermatologists say U.S. sunscreens have limited ingredients that filter the deeper-penetrating ultraviolet A rays. UVA rays, which can pass through window glass, cause premature aging and are associated with melanoma.

Four of the eight pending applications with the FDA are for ingredients that fight UVA rays, according to the Environmental Working Group, a consumer organization that puts out an annual report on sunscreens.

The best UVA filter in the United States is avobenzone, which is less effective than several products safely used in Europe for years, said Dr. Mary Lien, a dermatologist who practices at several Tampa Bay-area hospitals. Another kind of chemical UVA filters used in the United States, the benzophenones, have caused allergic reactions in some people, she added.

Certain physical blockers such as titanium oxide also work against UVA rays but are impractical for daily use because they deposit a chalky film that few users except lifeguards will tolerate.

In recent years, the FDA has toughened up labeling standards to help consumers pick the best “broad spectrum” sunscreens, those that protect against both UVA and UVB rays. For instance, the agency requires that sunscreens pass a test before they can be labeled broad-spectrum. Critics, including the Environmental Working Group, say that test isn’t stringent enough.

European countries, for instance, require that sunscreens offer UVA protection that is at least a third as potent as the UVB protection measured by SPF. The group estimates that half of the 456 U.S. sunscreens it evaluated this year would be too weak to be sold on the European market.

So do the weaker U.S. sunscreens result in higher skin-cancer rates than other countries? Dr. Steven Wang, director of dermatologic surgery and dermatology at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in New Jersey and a member of the PASS coalition, said that’s difficult to answer. That’s partly because so many people, in every country, aren’t using sunscreen correctly: They don’t reapply it nearly enough, he said, or they assume any use at all gives them license to bake.

“People think it makes them invincible,” he said.

View Our Other Blog Articles:

Transitioning Summer Skincare Into Fall

Top Tips for Taking Your Skin and Skincare from Summer to Fall Be honest – how well did you do with taking care of your skin this summer? Did you wear sunblock every day? Always stay out of the sun during peak hours?  We’re not here to judge! Whatever the condition of...

Demystifying Facial Fillers

For more than four decades, experts in the medical aesthetics field have been offering facial fillers. During that time, there have been plenty of changes in what is available, what the FDA has approved for cosmetic use, and the results patients can expect....

Attaining Your Ideal Body with Ozempic and CoolSculpting

If you pay attention to the latest options for maintaining your weight and sculpting your body, you’ve no doubt heard about the FDA-approved prescription medicationOzempic. A treatment for type 2 diabetes, the medicine has made headlines for its bonus benefit of...

Don’t Believe the Hype About PDO Thread Lifts

While searching for the latest and greatest in skin-rejuvenating treatment options or simply scrolling social media, you may have come across the PDO Thread Lift. This treatment has become popular on Instagram and TikTok videos with many influencers touting it as a...

Heading Into 2023 with Confidence

While you’ll find plenty of advice for choosing and keeping New Year’s Resolutions online, a couple that always seem to make the list are losing weight and getting in shape. In fact, earlier this year, 41% of U.S. adults characterized themselves as...

How to Head into the Holidays Looking and Feeling Your Best

The season for giving is upon us, and we have a feeling you will be giving a lot – of yourself. During these months of extra cooking, shopping, and hopefully plenty of celebrating, it’s more important than ever to carve out dedicated time for self-care. At Greenwich...

Tips for Transitioning Your Skincare from Summer to Fall

Pumpkin is everywhere, which can only mean one thing – the fall season has arrived. As you start packing away your summer wardrobe (sadly) and looking forward to autumn’s bright foliage, don’t forget to make some changes to your skincare routine too. Less sunlight,...

Top Summer Skincare Travel Tips from an Aesthetician

There is no question that as the seasons change, our skincare routine needs to adjust too. While winter months may have you reaching for more moisturizer, summer can leave you asking what the heck you can do to combat high temperatures, sweat, sun damage and other...

Top Aesthetic Treatments for Making Self-Care a Priority

Wife, mother, entrepreneur, friend, daughter – you take on many roles. In fact, there are probably times you have been so busy, the first thing that falls off your to do list is your own care. But taking care of yourself should be at the top of your list because it is...

Guys, Are You Losing Sleep Over Hair Loss?

There are plenty of things to worry about today, but a receding hairline or thinning hair shouldn’t be one of them. Yet many men, or more accurately most men, will eventually suffer noticeable hair loss. In fact, according to the American Hair Loss Association, about 66% of men will join this club by age 35, and by age 50, that goes up to 85%. Not that it helps to be in the […]